You can’t see the forest for the trees, so cut them down
New Jersey has come up with a strange new conservation philosophy: destroy the forest to save it.
The state says it wants to restore Atlantic white cedar in the Pinelands. That goal is important. Atlantic white cedar forests are disappearing, threatened by sea-level rise, saltwater intrusion, altered hydrology, deer browsing, and a long history of logging and development. New Jersey once had roughly 115,000 acres of Atlantic white cedar; today, fewer than 25,000 acres remain.
But if the answer to losing forests is to bring in heavy equipment, clear-cut public forests and use herbicides, we need to ask a very basic question: At what point does restoration start looking an awful lot like destruction?
This is a clear-cut problem
The New Jersey Forest Service’s Atlantic White Cedar Restoration Project is a massive effort: a $20 million, 10-year program intended to restore about 10,000 acres. The money comes from natural resource damage settlements involving groundwater pollution. The state says the project will help restore cedar forests, protect water resources, and increase climate resilience.
But public money recovered because polluters damaged New Jersey’s natural resources should be used with extraordinary care. It should not become a blank check for industrial-style forestry on public lands.
The Pinelands were preserved for future generations. They were not preserved so that commercial logging interests could treat public forests like a timber farm.
____________________________________________________
Daily energy and environment updates. Free 30-day subscription
You can’t see the forest for the trees, so cut them down Read More »




