Alan Dershowitz claims a fictional lawyer defamed him. The implications for novelists are very real.

Alan Dershowitz

By Ron Charles Critic, Book World, Washington Post

Alan Dershowitz, who is a real lawyer, claims he has been defamed by Benjamin Dafoe, who is a fictional lawyer.

Hang on, your honor. Things are about to get complicated.

“The Good Fight,” which streams on CBS All Access, frequently revolves around ripped-from-the-headlines events. On May 28, the legal drama aired an episode called “The Gang Discovers Who Killed Jeffrey Epstein,” about the wealthy sex offender who died in prison last year. On the show, Benjamin Dafoe, Epstein’s (fictional) former attorney, says he formed a very bad opinion of Epstein after “he ditched me for Dershowitz.” Then he adds: “At least I didn’t get a massage, like that shyster.”

In a letter sent to CBS and made public by Variety, Dershowitz’s lawyer claims that this episode is defamatory and constitutes “a direct attack on his professional reputation as an attorney and professor of law.” Dershowitz wants CBS to delete the offending dialogue and issue him a public apology.

Is ‘The Good Fight’ worth adding another streaming subscription? Afraid so.

A real-life lawyer for CBS responded with all the pluck and wit you would expect from a character on “The Good Fight.” “Benjamin Dafoe is not a real lawyer,” wrote attorney Jonathan Anschell. “. . . In other words, as one might explain to a small child, the Series, its characters and the things they say are all make-believe. People don’t watch the Series for factual information about Professor Dershowitz or anyone else.”

Dershowitz’s objection to “The Good Fight” may sound like a variant of the strange legal battle that Rep. Devin Nunes (R-Calif.) launched last year against a parodic cow on Twitter. But his complaint, if successful, could pose a challenge to the vibrancy of contemporary historical fiction and biographical fiction — indeed, to any creative work that includes interactions between fictional and real-life public figures.

Just this summer, for instance, several prominent writers have published novels that borrow, embellish and manipulate the details of well-known people’s lives. Their stories freely mingle fiction and nonfiction, statements people have said and statements they have never said. There are no footnotes in these novels to distinguish truth from fantasy, research from invention. Those elements are as hard to pick out as the lentils that Cinderella’s stepmother tossed in the ashes. (Note: A lawyer for Cinderella’s stepmother categorically denies that accusation.)

Read the full story

Don’t miss stories like this Click for EP Blog updates

Alan Dershowitz claims a fictional lawyer defamed him. The implications for novelists are very real. Read More »

New York Attorney General files suit to dissolve NRA

Letitia James, one of four Democrats seeking the nomination for state attorney general, speaks to the Times Union editorial board on Wednesday, Aug. 22, 2018, at Times Union in Colonie N.Y. (Will Waldron/Times Union)

Times Union

New York Attorney General Letitia James on Thursday said her office was filing a lawsuit to force the dissolution of the National Rifle Association.

James accused of the organization of illegal conduct for diverting millions of dollars from the NRA’s charitable mission to personal use by the organization’s leaders.

https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/Breaking-New-York-AG-files-suit-to-dissolve-NRA-15463653.php?utm_campaign=timesunion_breakingnews_20200806&utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=email#photo-16349920

New York Attorney General files suit to dissolve NRA Read More »

How coronavirus spread after a church service

Almost 100 people in Ohio were infected with coronavirus after man attended church service

By Steve Almasy, CNN
Updated 3 hours ago Aug 6, 2020

(CNN) – A man with Covid-19 went to church in mid-June, then 91 other people got sick, including 53 who were at the service, according to Ohio’s governor.

“It spread like wildfire, wildfire. Very, very scary,” Gov. MIke De Wine said Tuesday. “We know that our faith-based leaders want nothing more than to protect those who come to worship.”

To illustrate how one infected person can spread the virus, state health officials released a color graphic showing how the cases radiated to some who weren’t even at the service.

DeWine urged people attending religious services to wear masks. He had mandated wearing face coverings for people 10 and older on July 22. On Wednesday, he ordered children in schools to wear masks, with a few exceptions.

The governor said he was going to send letters to churches, mosques and synagogues to share important health information.

“It is vital that, any time people gather together, everyone wear masks, practice social distancing, wash hands, and while indoors, making sure there is good ventilation and airflow,” he said.

In the case of community spread from the worshipper at the undisclosed church, a 56-year-old man went to the service. A total of 53 people got sick and 18 of those churchgoers spread it to at least one other person.


One instance of spread was a family in which a 34-year-old man became sick. His 31-year-old wife also became infected, as did four children who range in age from 1 to 11.


The wife and two children of the 56-year-old worshipper mentioned by the governor also got sick. The state didn’t detail the seriousness of the 91 people’s illnesses.


More than 96,000 people in Ohio have tested positive for the coronavirus.


TM & © 2020 Turner Broadcasting System, Inc.
A WarnerMedia Company.
All Rights Reserved.

How coronavirus spread after a church service Read More »

Pa. Gov. Wolf recommends no high school sports until 2021; condemns delays in getting virus test results

By FORD TURNER THE MORNING CALL

Pa. Gov. Tom Wolf

Gov. Tom Wolf told reporters Thursday morning he recommended against conducting any high school sports until after Jan. 1 to prevent further spread of the coronavirus.

Wolf said the recommendation was based in the concept that the virus thrives in congregate settings.

“Anything that brings people together is going to help that virus get us,” Wolf said. “And we ought to do everything we can to defeat that virus.”

Health Secretary Dr. Rachel Levine, who appeared at the press conference with Wolf, said the latest data showed there were 807 more cases of the virus in Pennsylvania on Thursday, bringing the total since the pandemic began to 116,521.

There also were 38 more deaths reported, bringing the total to 7,282. The 38 figure was the largest one-day increase in the state’s death total in more than a month.

Wolf’s statements on high school sports came at the tail end of a press conference focused on virus testing. He and Levine appeared with a Walmart executive, Jamie Reilly, who expanded on a previously announced testing partnership between the state and Walmart.

Read the full story

EnviroPolitics Blog is working to keep you informed about all aspects of the coronavirus — the status of confirmed cases, disease spread, death toll–and also how Americans are coping. Like this story, for instance. If you like what we are doing, Click to receive free EP Blog updates and please tell your friends about us.

Pa. Gov. Wolf recommends no high school sports until 2021; condemns delays in getting virus test results Read More »

DRBC’s climate-change advisory panel organizes; selects Howard Neukrug of Penn’s Water Center as chairman

Delaware River

Delaware River Basin Commission news release

WEST TRENTON, N.J. (August 6, 2020) — As Tropical Storm Isaias roared up through the Delaware Valley Tuesday, the Delaware River Basin Commission’s (DRBC) Advisory Committee on Climate Change (ACCC) held its inaugural meeting. The ACCC was created by the DRBC in December 2019. The ACCC is comprised of 18 individuals with relevant climate expertise, representing various government, watershed, academic, business and water user perspectives.

The ACCC’s initial charge is to help inform DRBC’s future water resource planning efforts considering climate change and support development of a comprehensive study on climate impacts to the Basin’s water supply and water quality.

“Here in the Delaware River Basin we have some unique challenges. This Basin is prone to droughts and floods. Our main stem river is undammed and open to the ocean, meaning the bay and estuary are subject to sea level rise and storm surges. Bottom line – it’s complex, and we need this regional climate change expert committee’s help,” said Steve Tambini, DRBC’s Executive Director.

Among the Committee’s first orders of business was to elect a chair. Howard Neukrug, P.E., Executive Director, The Water Center at Penn, University of Pennsylvania, was unanimously chosen by the members.

“The DRBC staff has assembled a strong team of climate experts who will now work together to share their knowledge and ideas on how to minimize the future impacts of climate change on our region’s water resources,” said Neukrug.

The ACCC is one of seven DRBC advisory committees, which are important forums for information-sharing, dialogue and coordination among stakeholders and member state agencies. These committees also help inform the Commission’s policy decisions. All advisory committee and sub-committee meetings are open to the public. Information on each is available at https://www.nj.gov/drbc/about/advisory/.

The DRBC is a federal/interstate government agency created in 1961 by concurrent compact legislation, marking the first time that the federal government and a group of states joined together as equal partners in a river basin planning, development and regulatory agency. The five Commission members are the governors of the basin states (Delaware, New Jersey, New York and Pennsylvania) and the commander of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’ North Atlantic Division, who represents the federal government.

Don’t miss stories like this Click for free EnviroPolitics Blog updates

DRBC’s climate-change advisory panel organizes; selects Howard Neukrug of Penn’s Water Center as chairman Read More »

Study backs up concerns that low-density residential land use threatens Lancaster County farmland

BAY JOURNAL

Farmland Aug. 3, 2020

When the American Farmland Trust recently assessed threats to farmland in Pennsylvania, it was surprised to find that urban sprawl and anemic profit margins for milk and crops didn’t top the list.

The biggest problem? The growth of large-lot subdivisions leapfrogging urban areas and popping up in farm country.

In its nationwide study, “Farms Under Threat: The State of the States,” the trust found that Pennsylvania ranked eighth in the nation for the rate of conversion from agricultural land to low-density housing. In fact, 70% of the 347,000 acres of farmland lost in the state between 2001 and 2016 was because of such pop-up neighborhoods.

Fragmenting of the agrarian landscape and the disruption of agricultural economies often leads to a slow but inexorable domino effect. While being amid new neighborhoods may benefit some farmers in the near term with direct-market sales, it’s more likely that over time the critical mass needed for a viable farm community is lost.

Farmers have trouble moving equipment between their fields, and new residents complain about odors. Grain and equipment retailers that farmers depend on move out and land prices go up, making it harder for farmers to buy property.

Low-density residential development is 23 times more likely to make surrounding ag land urbanized than other agricultural land, according to the report, which the trust bills as “the most comprehensive assessment ever undertaken of U.S. agricultural land use.”

“While urban sprawl is still a threat to farmland, low-density residential land use is as much of a threat to farmland as urbanization,” said Jamie Mierau, American Farmland Trust’s mid-Atlantic regional director. “Unlike urban highly developed development, conversion to low-density residential is not closely tied to population growth.”

Read the full story

We’re always looking for stories that might interest our readers. If you come across something so interesting that it cries out to be shared, please send it to editor@enviropolitics.com  If we agree, you’ll see it here soon.   

Study backs up concerns that low-density residential land use threatens Lancaster County farmland Read More »